I have about 700 pieces, most of which are on display in my office. Like this:
A bear to dust but I truly do enjoy them and love having them around me when I work in my upstairs office.
Recently an extensive new value guide came out for the Breyers by Lynn Anderson, who has been tracking values since the mid 1990s. She knows her stuff and is reputable among the hobby. So, not having valued my collection since well before we moved back to Indiana in 2006, and knowing I would have some time on my hands as I healed from my surgery this summer, I decided to purchase her guide and see how much my Breyers were worth.
My estimate? Between $10,000 and possibly $15,000. After all, I have some early pieces which are quite valuable (a bonus from having collected so long) plus some unusual finishes and such.
Like the buckskin Indiana Pony with warpaint.
The early glossy dapple grey Clydesdale.
The black Grazing Mare and Foal plus the stretch Morgan with old-style black hooves.
A rare chalky (made during the 70s oil shortage when Breyer changed its plastics recipe.)
I've got a pearly finish Lying Foal (alongside a regular one.)
I've got old models with eyewhites and other oddities (none of which did I count into the value - I strictly did the value of the piece in a regular finish.)
After going through all my Breyer pieces one by one, pulling out boxed up ones in the closet, and recording them in the value guide, I tallied up the value and was stunned to see the figure.
$27,945.
Yes, you read that right. BIG GULP. Even more sobering is that I did not value my Hartlands, my Hagen Renakers, my Beswicks, my North Lights, Japans, or any others. This is just the Breyers. And, just like the Breyers, since I have been collecting so long, I have some really old and unusual pieces among the other brands.
I am thinking it might be a good idea to look into insurance for my collection.










